Each participant is randomized to one of three treatment groups:
- Intensive lifestyle intervention.
- Metformin with standard lifestyle recommendations.
- A metformin placebo with standard lifestyle recommendations.
Follow-up visits will be scheduled at 3-month intervals throughout the duration
of the DPP. Participants assigned to the intensive lifestyle intervention will have
more frequent scheduled follow-up visits to implement the program of weight reduction
and increased calorie expenditure. Participants assigned to the two pharmacological
treatments (metformin or placebo) will be scheduled for one visit one month after
randomization for dose titration. All randomized participants will continue their
scheduled follow-up visits for the duration of DPP regardless of their level of
compliance with the assigned treatment. Outcome and safety assessments will be conducted
according to the schedule in section 12.2.
1.1 Interim Visits
An interim visit refers to all visits other than scheduled follow-up visits (i.e.,
standard or major follow-up visits). Interim visits may be required for the monitoring
or management of an emerging or existing condition, or to repeat procedures that,
at a previous visit, were found to be deficient. Such visits may be held as frequently
as deemed necessary.
1.2 Suspension of Follow-up Visits
The occurrence or presence of the following will constitute inactive follow-up and
suspension of the scheduled follow-up protocol:
- Voluntary withdrawal by the participant, or
- A condition that, in the opinion of the principal investigator, makes it unsafe
for the participant to continue.
Efforts to return participants to an active status will be made regularly, as appropriate.
[Top]
2. Standard Lifestyle Recommendations
- After randomization, all participants will receive the following standard lifestyle
recommendations.
At the first visit, the staff will spend approximately 20-30 minutes with each participant
individually, reviewing the importance of a healthy lifestyle for the prevention
of NIDDM, and for prevention and treatment of other diseases (such as cardiovascular
disease and hypertension). Materials, provided by the Lifestyle Resource Core, will
be given to each participant, and the staff will review the basic information in
the materials with the participant. The materials will include information or recommendations
on
- Healthy Eating--The Food Pyramid is used as the basis of discussion. Participants
are encouraged to consume the equivalent of a NCEP Step I diet.
- Healthy Weight--The materials include a weight chart, a description of how to measure
one's own waist, and guidelines for appropriate waist circumferences. The materials
include discussion of the benefits of modest weight reduction (5-10% of initial
weight) for those who are overweight and describe general behavior changes that
can be made to produce weight loss. Changes in both dietary intake and exercise
are recommended for weight loss and maintenance.
- Physical Activity--Participants are encouraged to adopt and maintain a more active
lifestyle. The materials suggest ways to increase general activity (such as using
stairs instead of elevators) and provide a chart with information regarding the
number of calories used in 10 minutes of various forms of exercise. Participants
are encouraged to increase their activity gradually and to try to reach the goal
of at least 30 minutes of physical activity (such as walking or biking) on 5 days
each week.
- Smoking--All participants who smoke are strongly encouraged to stop smoking. The
materials include general information about the health risks associated with smoking,
the benefits and specific strategies for stopping smoking, and a list of programs
available to participants to help them stop smoking. Participants are encouraged
to read the materials carefully, to bring any questions they have to the next visit,
and to try to gradually work toward a healthier lifestyle.
- Alcohol Intake--Participants, especially those in the pharmacological treatment
groups due to the nature of the medication used in the DPP, are informed of the
need to avoid excessive alcohol intake (see
section 5.2.3) and binge drinking.
- At the end-month 3 follow-up visit, the staff briefly review the materials with
the participant. The staff answer any questions regarding the information provided.
- At yearly intervals (soon after each annual assessment), the staff meet with each
participant to review the information on diet, exercise, weight, and smoking.
[Top]
The goals of therapy for participants randomly assigned to the intensive lifestyle
intervention are two:
- Achieve a weight reduction of at least 7% of initial weight and maintain this weight
reduction throughout the DPP.
- Achieve at least 150 minutes/week of moderate intensity exercise (such as walking
and bicycling) and maintain this level of physical activity throughout the DPP.
Recognizing that it is very difficult to produce long-term changes in eating and
exercise behaviors and in body weight, the intensive lifestyle intervention is designed
to maximize the chances of achieving and maintaining these goals. The intensive
lifestyle intervention is based on the premise that long-term changes in diet and
exercise and sustained motivation to maintain behavior changes are most likely to
occur in an intensive intervention that includes the following:
- Training in diet, exercise, and behavior modification skills
- On-going contact with participants and continued, frequent (no less than monthly)
support for behavior change
- Diet and exercise interventions that are flexible and sensitive to cultural differences
and acceptable in the specific communities in which they are implemented
- A combination of individual and group intervention
- A combination of a structured protocol (in which all participants receive certain
common information) and the flexibility to tailor strategies individually to help
a specific participant achieve and maintain the study goals
- Emphasis on self-esteem, empowerment, and social support
3.1 Description of Program
- Lifestyle Resource Core
The Lifestyle Resource Core, located at the University of Pittsburgh, developed
the materials for the intensive lifestyle intervention and will provide on-going
training and support for the case managers.
- Staff for Intensive Lifestyle Intervention
Case managers at each clinical center will carry out the intensive lifestyle intervention.
Case managers will be individuals with experience in nutrition, exercise, and/or
behavior modification and will receive further training from the Lifestyle Resource
Core. The case managers are supported by staff at each center with additional expertise
in nutrition, exercise, or behavior modification. Each participant randomized to
the intensive lifestyle intervention is assigned a case manager who will work with
him or her throughout the DPP (changing case managers for a specific participant
may be necessary to help retain participants in the DPP or to help participants
achieve the weight and exercise goals).
Other staff (e.g. peer counselors and exercise leaders) are employed as appropriate
at each center.
- Format of Intervention
- 16-Session Core Curriculum
Participants randomized to the intensive lifestyle intervention will participate
in a 16-session core curriculum. This initial intervention will commence as soon
as possible after randomization, and must begin within 2-3 months after randomization.
These 16 sessions are to be held over 24 weeks. These initial 16 sessions will be
individual sessions involving the participant and case manager; however, small groups
may be formed if all members of a small group start and complete the 16 sessions
together (closed group format). In addition, a spouse or other key family member
may be invited to attend. The first 8 sessions and 4 of the following 8 sessions
must be with the case manager; the other 4 or more sessions may be with the case
manager, a peer-counselor, home visitor, or the equivalent. Topics and lesson materials
to be utilized in this 16-session core curriculum have been developed by the Lifestyle
Resource Core and are in the Lifestyle Intervention Manual. Topics included in this
16-session core curriculum include
- Lifestyle change as a way to prevent diabetes: the importance of healthier eating
and exercise behavior.
- Looking at what you eat--self-monitoring of eating behavior.
- Reducing fat intake--identifying high fat foods and appropriate lower fat alternatives.
- Looking at your physical activity--self-monitoring of activity.
- Increasing your physical activity--identifying activities that can be maintained
long term.
- Changing the environment to promote lower fat and lower calorie intake (stimulus
control techniques and shopping skills).
- Strategies for increasing exercise and reducing the barriers to exercise.
- Eating at home--food preparation and recipe modification skills to lower fat and
calorie intake.
- Eating away from home--strategies for dieting in restaurants and other social eating
situations.
- Problem solving.
The schedule of visits represents the minimum frequency of contact and can be adjusted
for individual participants due to personal constraints such as illness, vacation,
and travel. Participants will be taught to record their diet and exercise throughout
the initial core curriculum phase of the program. The emphasis of the first 24 weeks
will be on achieving the 7% weight loss goal and to achieve at least 150 minutes/week
of moderate intensity exercise and maintain this level of physical activity throughout
the DPP. If participants are having difficulty achieving either or both of these
goals, a "tool box" approach will be used to add new strategies to help
individual participants achieve the weight and exercise goals. The Lifestyle Resource
Core will be responsible for providing an initial list of tool box strategies, and
individual case managers can propose additional strategies to the Core for their
review. Tool box strategies to increase physical activity would include approaches
such as provision of home exercise equipment to the participant or enrolling the
participant in a local health club. Tool box strategies for weight loss would include
strategies such as increased clinic visits, home visits, and provision of low calorie
meals or frozen entrees to the participant.
- Maintenance Phase
Following the initial phase, all participants in the intensive lifestyle intervention
will receive, at a minimum, monthly contacts for the remainder of the DPP. At least
one contact every 2 months must be in person and must be done by the case manager.
The other contact can be by phone. In addition, starting in the second half of year
01 of intensive lifestyle intervention, "short courses" will be offered
quarterly for those intensive lifestyle participants who wish to attend. Each course
will last 4-6 weeks and will focus on a specific topic. Exercise courses will include
such topics as resistance training or step aerobics. Nutrition topics might include
recipe swap, holiday entertaining, or stir fry cooking. Behavioral topics might
include "keeping lapses from becoming relapses," "emotions and eating,"
or "getting my family involved." All participants who have completed the
16-session core curriculum will be invited to attend these classes and those participants
having problems in specific areas (e.g., not getting enough exercise) will be strongly
encouraged to join the appropriate class. The number of participants in these classes
and the group make-up will thus differ for each topic. Individual centers will be
able to propose ideas for "classes" and some flexibility will be given
to centers in terms of which classes to offer (i.e., not all centers will have to
offer the same classes), although all centers may need to offer one class related
to diet, one to exercise, and one to a behavioral topic each year. Curricula for
the 4-6 week classes will be developed by the Lifestyle Resource Core, with input
from the individual centers. New classes will be introduced each year.
- Exercise Sessions
Each center will offer two supervised exercise sessions per week. These group exercise
sessions may be held at churches, health centers, outdoors, etc. Any type of low
intensity activity may be used (such as walking or aerobic dancing). These sessions
are provided as an option for participants to increase their exercise. Centers can
choose specific staff members to offer these sessions, which will be offered throughout
the DPP; however, if sufficient numbers of participants are not utilizing these
sessions, this aspect of the protocol may be modified.
3.2 Indices of Adherence
Adherence to the intensive lifestyle intervention is assessed in the following manner:
- Data are recorded on all face-to-face contacts and phone contacts to ensure that
all intensive lifestyle intervention participants receive the 16 core curriculum
sessions and monthly contacts throughout the study. Attendance at supervised exercise
sessions and group classes is documented (although these are not required of participants).
- Adherence to exercise protocol is determined from self-report questionnaires that
assess physical activity, completed at screening step 3, end-months 6 and 12, and
then annually, thereafter, in all DPP participants and with intensive lifestyle
intervention diaries.
- Adherence to the weight loss goal is determined from the 6-month assessments of
body weight.
[Top]
4. Pharmacological Treatment
4.1 Description
In addition to the intensive lifestyle intervention, there is one pharmacological
intervention and a placebo control group. Metformin 850 mg bid is the pharmacological
intervention. A corresponding placebo is used to achieve a randomized, placebo controlled,
double masked research design. The following codes are used in this section: MP--metformin
placebo and MA--metformin active (850 mg). Metformin is an investigational drug
for the treatment of IGT and will be used under an Investigative New Drug (IND)
application with the Food and Drug Administration (FDA).
- Metformin
Metformin is an antihyperglycemic drug of the biguanide class used in the management
of non-insulin-dependent diabetes (NIDDM) in over 90 countries for over 30 years.
It was approved for use in the U.S. in 1995 and is distributed by Bristol-Myers
Squibb under the trade name Glucophage and manufactured by Lipha, a French pharmaceutical
firm.
Metformin reduces the excess hepatic glucose production that characterizes NIDDM
without increasing insulin secretion (see
section 3.7.1). With reduced hyperglycemia, glucose uptake by muscle and
other insulin sensitive tissues is enhanced while insulin levels remain stable or
decline. In addition to its antihyperglycemic action, metformin also has antihyperlipidemic
effects, particularly the lowering of serum triglyceride levels, and is sometimes
associated with weight loss.
Metformin is related to phenformin, an agent used in the U.S. in the late 60's and
early 70's but withdrawn from use because of the occurrence of severe, often fatal,
lactic acidosis. Metformin has been found to cause lactic acidosis rarely (about
0.03 cases per 1,000 person years) and then only when used in persons with renal
or hepatic insufficiency or during episodes of hypoxia or circulatory failure.
Before its 1995 release in the U.S., and after review of extensive metformin use
in Canada, Europe, and other parts of the world, Bristol-Myers Squibb issued an
FDA approved package insert providing detailed contraindications, precautions, and
safety monitoring recommendations for its use in NIDDM. During the DPP all of these
recommendations (including periodic assessment of serum creatinine) are strictly
adhered to and the maximum dosage used (1.7 gm/day) is less than the maximum recommended
(2.55 gm/day).
Metformin is not currently approved for use as a preventive for the development
of NIDDM. However, some studies suggest that metformin may be effective in persons
with impaired glucose tolerance, similar to those in the DPP, by reducing hepatic
glucose release, enhancing insulin sensitivity, or through other mechanisms such
as weight loss.
The most common side effects associated with metformin are gastrointestinal. As
many as 30% of persons report diarrhea, nausea, metallic taste, abdominal bloating,
flatulence, or anorexia. These symptoms are generally transient, resolve spontaneously,
and can be avoided by gradual escalation of dosage. Metformin is not associated
with hypoglycemia unless used in conjunction with other glucose lowering medications
(sulfonylurea or insulin). About 4% of participants were unable to continue metformin
in U.S. clinical trials.
About 6-9% of participants on metformin develop reduced vitamin B12 levels. However,
megaloblastic anemia is rare, and metformin use has not been reported to cause peripheral
neuropathy.
4.2 Dosing Schedule
The administration of coded medication, either active or placebo, takes place in
three phases: run-in and post-randomization steps I and II. The use of metformin
at the dose of 850 mg twice daily is associated with gastrointestinal side effects
at the onset of treatment. These side effects are reduced if the medication is taken
with food and the dose titrated from once daily to twice daily over several weeks.
Thus, metformin will be administered with food and the dose (MP or MA) will be increased
in two steps during the DPP.
4.2.1 Pre-randomization
All DPP candidates participate in a 3-week run-in phase during eligibility screening
in which participants take MP (metformin-placebo) twice daily, in the morning and
evening with food (see section 6.2.3).
Participants will be told that the pills are inactive during the run-in.
4.2.2 Post-Randomization--Steps I and II
Volunteers who successfully complete the run-in phase and are otherwise eligible
are randomized to one of the three DPP treatments: intensive lifestyle intervention
group, placebo control group, or metformin group. Volunteers randomized to one of
the two pharmacological treatments then enter Step I of the pharmacological treatment
regimen.
Step I
After randomization, pharmacological participants initially take one tablet with
the morning meal. This is MP in the placebo control group and MA in the metformin
group. This phase will last 4 weeks.
Step II
After 4 weeks in Step I (once daily dosage), participants are advanced to Step II
(twice daily dosage). This is MP BID in the placebo control group and MA BID in
the metformin group.
Table 1. Summary of Coded Medication Administration
|
Step
|
Week
|
Time*
|
Placebo**
|
Metformin**
|
|
Run-in
|
-3 to 0
|
AM
PM
|
PM
PM
|
PM
PM
|
|
Step I
|
0 to 4
|
AM
PM
|
PM
None
|
AM
None
|
|
Step II
|
>4
|
AM
PM
|
PM
PM
|
AM
AM
|
*AM--Usually before breakfast; may be before first meal of the day
PM--Usually before evening meal; may be taken before bedtime snack.
** M--metformin, A--active, P--placebo
4.3 Restarts and Titration Due to Potential Non-Gastrointestinal Side Effects
If non-gastrointestinal side effects considered likely to be due to coded medications
occur and require cessation of coded medications during Step I, all coded medications
will be stopped for 4 weeks. If the non-gastrointestinal symptoms disappear, a second
attempt to introduce coded medications is made after 4 weeks. If symptoms re-occur,
the coded medications will again be discontinued. A third try may be attempted after
6 months and a fourth try after another 6 months.
Potential non-gastrointestinal side effects include, but are not limited to headache,
mild edema, leg cramps, arthralgia, myalgia, dizziness, mild rashes, and dysmenorrhea.
If non-gastrointestinal side effects occur that are considered likely due to coded
medications during Step II, the participant will drop back to the Step I dosing
schedule for 4 weeks. A second attempt to restart Step II is made after 4 weeks.
If symptoms re-occur during this second attempt to implement Step II, the participant
is restarted at Step I for 6 months. A third attempt to restart Step II is made
after 6 months. If this third attempt fails, the participant will be maintained
at Step I for the remainder of the DPP. Gastrointestinal side effects are handled
as indicated below.
4.4 Safety Monitoring and Measures to Reduce and Manage Potentially Drug-Related
Side Effects
- Laboratory Safety Monitoring
During the DPP all participants assigned to one of the two pharmacological treatment
groups will have periodic laboratory tests to assess possible toxic effects on the
hepatic, hematopoietic, and renal systems. These include
- ALT and AST (liver enzymes) measured at end-months 3 and 6, and then every 6 months.
- A CBC with differential count at end-months 6 and 12, and then yearly.
- A serum creatinine every 6 months during the DPP.
In addition, women of childbearing age will have pregnancy tests when necessary
based on symptoms and menstrual history.
- Discontinuation of Coded Medication Use During Hospitalizations
Metformin should not be used in patients with hypoxia or circulatory failure and
should be discontinued before the administration of contrast dyes and surgery requiring
general anesthesia. To avoid having metformin administered inadvertently to hospitalized
DPP participants in whom it may be contraindicated, all coded medications will be
discontinued during hospitalizations. DPP testing of glucose tolerance will be delayed
until coded medications have been resumed for at least 2 weeks. However, glucose
tolerance testing will be performed within 6 weeks even if coded medications have
not been restarted, assuming that the patient does not have a concomitant condition
that substantially interferes with glucose tolerance. However, if the participant
has a serious condition (e.g. recovering from major surgery, on high doses of steroids,
ongoing fibrile illnesses) known to affect the glucose tolerance adversely, the
testing will be postponed until the next regularly scheduled testing of glucose
tolerance.
- Gastrointestinal Symptoms
These include diarrhea, abdominal pain, vomiting, nausea, a metallic taste, bloating,
flatulence, and anorexia. They are more likely to occur with metformin but may occur
with placebo. If these symptoms are mild and tolerable, coded medications will be
continued.
If they are moderate or difficult to tolerate, they will be presumed initially to
be due to metformin and the protocol for reductions from Step II to Step I and Step
I to temporary cessation will be implemented only for the coded metformin. If, after
1 week, these gastrointestinal symptoms are not alleviated by reducing or stopping
MP or MA, all coded medications will be stopped. Coded medications may be restarted
after 4 weeks at Step I. If coded medications cannot be tolerated on this second
attempt, a third restart can be attempted at 6 months. A fourth and final restart
can be implemented after another 6 months.
In the event that diarrhea, abdominal pain, or vomiting becomes severe enough to
cause dehydration or volume depletion, all coded medications will be discontinued
immediately and the participant will be evaluated and treated appropriately. Once
dehydration or severe pain has resolved, coded medications can be restarted at the
previous dose.
- Renal Insufficiency
Serum creatinine safety measurements will be made every 6 months in all participants
in the pharmacological treatment groups of the DPP. Metformin is not known to cause
renal insufficiency. However, it is associated with an increased risk for lactic
acidosis if used in persons whose glomerular filtration or creatinine clearance
rates are below 60 mL/min (per 1.73 m2 surface area). Thus, metformin
use is contraindicated with serum creatinine
1.5 mg/dL [133 m mol/L] in men and
1.4 mg/dL [124 m mol/L] in women. If either condition occurs during the study, coded
metformin (MP or MA) will be discontinued and serum creatinine rechecked in 2 weeks.
Coded metformin will be restarted if the repeat serum creatinine is < 1.5 mg/dL
in men or < 1.4 mg/dL in women. If the serum creatinine is again
1.5 mg/dL [133 m mol/L] in men or
1.4 mg/dL [124 m mol/L] in women, an evaluation of potential causes of renal insufficiency
will be made. Coded metformin will also be discontinued in individuals who have
a post-randomization creatinine clearance (based on a 24 hour urine collection)
level < 75 mL/min. A creatinine clearance is only performed post-randomization
if the participant turns 80 years old during the DPP and did not receive a creatinine
clearance for eligibility.
- Anemia
A CBC will be determined for safety reasons at end-months 6 and 12, and at yearly
intervals thereafter, in all participants in the pharmacological treatment groups.
If anemia (defined as a hematocrit < 36.0% in men and < 33.0% in women) or
significant macrocytosis develops, or if the hematocrit decreases by 4 or more points
from the level at study entry (e.g., from 44% to 40%), the CBC and differential
will be repeated within 1 month. This evaluation will include measurement of serum
B12 levels and exploration of other causes of anemia or macrocytosis, as indicated.
Coded medication may be continued if the cause of the anemia is identified and treated.
This includes the administration of vitamin B12 when indicated.
- Hepatotoxicity
Hepatic enzymes (ALT and AST) will be measured at end-months 3 and 6, and then every
6 months, in all participants in the pharmacological treatment groups of the DPP.
Hepatic enzyme elevations are rare with metformin and may be no more frequent than
with placebo. Nevertheless, metformin should not be used in persons with known active
liver disease or hepatic insufficiency.
If either ALT or AST level is 1.8 times the upper limit of normal or higher, search
for other causes (history, physical, and local laboratory tests including direct
and total bilirubin, albumin, prothrombin time, and serologies for hepatitis A,
B, and C, which should be performed locally) and proceed as follows:
1. If either ALT or AST level is 1.8-3.0 times the upper limit of normal:
a. Continue coded medication and
b. Repeat liver function tests at CBL every 2 weeks for 6 weeks or until level returns
to less than 1.8 times the upper limit of normal.
c. If ALT or AST remains 1.8-3.0 times the upper limit of normal, continue coded
medication at discretion of investigator with continued monitoring of ALT and AST
levels at the CBL at scheduled quarterly follow-up visits for the next year followed
by the protocol schedule of liver function testing.
d. If ALT or AST is < 1.8 times the upper limit of normal, continue coded medication
and the protocol schedule of liver function testing.
2. If either ALT or AST is > 3.0 times the upper limit of normal:
a. Stop coded medication immediately and
b. Repeat liver function tests at CBL every week for 6 weeks or until level returns
to less than 1.8 times the upper limit of normal.
c. If ALT or AST remains 1.8-3.0 times the upper limit of normal, re-challenge the
coded medication at discretion of investigator (since metformin is not associated
with liver disease) with continued monitoring of ALT and AST levels at the CBL at
scheduled quarterly follow-up visits for the next year followed by the protocol
schedule of liver function testing.
d. If ALT or AST is < 1.8 times the upper limit of normal, re-challenge coded
medication and the protocol schedule of liver function testing.
Participants are instructed that in the event they develop malaise, nausea, vomiting,
dark urine, jaundice, or right upper quadrant abdominal discomfort, they should
stop coded medication and report the symptoms immediately to their DPP clinical
center. Upon notification, the clinical center staff must obtain a blood sample
as soon as possible (within 1 week) for liver function tests at the CBL. If both
ALT and AST are less than 1.8 times the upper limit of normal, the participant may
be re-challenged with the coded medication. If either value is > 1.8 times the
upper limit of normal, then follow testing procedures outlined above.
- Pregnancy and Nursing
If a woman plans to become pregnant or becomes pregnant, coded medication will be
discontinued. Following the pregnancy and nursing, the coded medication will be
restarted at the Step I dosage level and then progressed to Step II as outlined
above. See the Pregnancy Protocol, section
7.5.4, for more details about coded medication unmasking and use following
pregnancy.
- Radiological Studies Using Contrast Dyes
Because of the potential danger of contrast induced renal insufficiency and lactic
acidosis associated with metformin, under these conditions, coded medication will
be discontinued for 48 hours before administration of contrast dyes and then restarted
48 hours after the dye administration, assuming that the serum creatinine levels
are in an acceptable range (< 1.5 mg/dL [133 m mol/L] for men and < 1.4 mg/dL
[124 m mol/L] for women). A wallet ID will be given to all participants and a warning
letter will be sent to all primary care providers to alert them to the fact that
participants may be taking metformin and that coded medication needs to be discontinued
prior to any radiological studies involving contrast dyes.
- Lactic Acidosis
Metformin may rarely be associated with the development of lactic acidosis, defined
as a metabolic acidosis with lactate
5.0 mM. If hospitalization or an unexplained metabolic acidosis occurs, coded medication
will be discontinued immediately and not restarted. The participant will be treated
appropriately.
- Hypoxic States--Congestive Heart Failure
States of hypoxia or hypoperfusion, including acute congestive heart failure and
acute myocardial infarction, may lead to lactic acidosis and require discontinuation
of coded medication and treatment of the underlying condition. If the underlying
hypoxic state is corrected or if CHF is transient (for example, after an acute MI),
reinstitution of coded medication may be considered. Medication arm participants
who develop CHF (NYHA Functional Class > 2) during the study should have their
coded medication stopped. Medication arm participants who develop NYHA Functional
Class 2 and require a loop diuretic or digitalis preparation should have their coded
medication stopped.
- Surgical Procedures
Because of the risk of metabolic acidosis during general anesthesia and major surgical
procedures, coded medication will be discontinued at least for 48 hours prior to
any anticipated surgical procedures. Coded medication will obviously be held while
participants are NPO for outpatient procedures. The most recent dose of the coded
medication can be reinstituted after the procedure when oral medications are allowed.
If an outpatient procedure is scheduled, a letter will be sent to surgeons to alert
them to the fact that coded medication must be discontinued prior to surgery.
- Dermatological Reactions
In the event of major dermatological reactions such as generalized urticaria, bullous
rashes, exfoliative dermatitis, or Stevens Johnson syndrome, coded medication will
be discontinued immediately and not restarted. For localized skin reactions, coded
medication may be discontinued if the skin reactions are potentially drug related.
If the rashes clear, coded medication may be restarted after 4 weeks, starting at
the Step I dosage level and then progressing to Step II after another 4 weeks. If
localized skin reactions recur with restarting the coded medication, coded medication
should be discontinued.
- Headaches
Metformin has sometimes been associated with transient headaches, although not more
frequently than placebo. However, headache is not a reason to decrease or discontinue
the coded medication unless severe and no other causes are found.
4.5 Indices of Adherence
The goal of the pharmacological treatment is to optimize adherence to the pharmacological
regimen, while maximizing retention of participants in the DPP. Assessment of adherence
to prescribed coded medication will provide clinic staff a means to identify participants
having problems with adherence.
Adherence to the pharmacological treatment will be assessed by the following:
- By visual inspection of participant's returned pill containers: the case manager
will estimate percent of prescribed coded medication taken.
- By conducting a brief, structured interview, the case manager will assist participants
to (a) identify problems in adherence to the pharmacological treatment and (b) estimate
adherence to the prescribed protocol since their previous visit.
Results of the case managers' adherence estimate and the interview with participant
will guide the consideration of strategies to improve adherence.
[Top]
5. Definition and Management of Concomitant Conditions
Clinical centers are neither sufficiently staffed nor funded to provide all primary
care or ancillary care to participants involved in DPP. Whenever possible and acceptable
to the referring primary care provider, conditions significantly affecting either
the primary or secondary outcomes of the DPP should be cared for as specified by
protocol within the context of the DPP in order to protect the integrity of the
DPP research questions. In addition, treatments for concomitant conditions which
could potentially affect either the primary or secondary outcomes should be avoided.
The following sections provide guidelines for therapy which should be vigorously
pursued. However, investigators and staff must be sensitive and at times flexible
with regard to the prerogative and needs of the primary care providers who have
a participant enrolled in DPP. If the following conditions arise during the course
of DPP, the investigator will contact the primary care provider by letter, informing
him/her of the condition and providing a copy of the treatment options developed
for DPP participants. Discussions with the primary care provider should be conducted
in the spirit of negotiation and collegiality, with the intent of including the
referring primary care provider in DPP operations. Treatment of all other conditions
not directly related to DPP outcomes will be treated by referring primary care providers,
community resources, or the clinical center as determined by referral patterns.
Participants with concomitant conditions who otherwise meet eligibility criteria
will remain on their pre-enrollment therapy.
5.1 Hypertension
There is a strong association between NIDDM and hypertension, apparently independent
of age and obesity (Modan, et al., 1985; Yudkin, 1991). Based on available cross-sectional
data, a cohort of participants in the likely age range for the DPP will include
a high proportion (~35%) who will have hypertension. Following are recommendations
for treatment:
- Goals of Therapy:
- Therapy should aim at maintaining BP <140/90 mm Hg. However, in participants
over age 60, the initial goal of therapy should be to lower SBP to <160 mm Hg
for those participants with SBP >180 mm Hg and to lower blood pressure by 20
mm Hg for those with SBP between 160 and 179 mm Hg. If this is well-tolerated, blood
pressure should be lowered to target levels noted above.
- At SBP levels of 140 to 160 mm Hg in participants with isolated systolic hypertension,
life-style modifications may be sufficient to lower blood pressure. Antihypertensive
drug therapy should be carried out more cautiously in older participants. Blood
pressure measurements may be required in the standing as well as seated positions,
and antihypertensive treatment should be initiated with smaller doses than usual.
- Therapy:
- Diet: Non-pharmacologic therapy should be employed initially, consisting of a prudent
diet aimed at weight reduction if necessary and moderate sodium restriction (<
2.3 g of sodium), limitation of alcohol intake, and encouragement of physical activity.
The participant and primary care provider will receive a standard printed set of
instructions outlining the goals. Participants will be advised to lose weight if
overweight, limit alcohol intake to < 1 oz per day of ethanol, to exercise aerobically
regularly, to maintain adequate potassium, calcium, and magnesium intake, to stop
smoking, and to reduce dietary saturated fat and cholesterol intake. These guidelines
will reinforce the standard lifestyle recommendations already in place for DPP.
If the blood pressure does not fall into an acceptable range after 4-6 weeks, then
pharmacologic therapy should be recommended.
- Drug therapy should be based on specific needs of the participants, potential side
effects of therapy, and consideration of other factors such as cost and availability.
The following classes of agents can be employed as first-line agents; substitution
and/or addition of drugs should be considered if blood pressure targets are not
attained.
- Angiotensin converting enzyme inhibitors.
- Calcium channel antagonists.
- Alpha adrenergic blockers.
- Centrally acting alpha2-agonists
Because of their potential to worsen glucose intolerance, diuretic agents should
be strongly discouraged for the treatment of hypertension in DPP participants (Bengtsson,
et al., 1984; Skarfors, et al., 1989; MRC Working Party, 1981; Saxman, et al., 1994).
When indicated for the treatment of edematous states or congestive heart failure,
diuretics may be used with caution, and will be noted in the subsequent data analysis
as a confounding variable. This applies to all diuretic therapy including thiazide
and loop diuretics; there should be careful monitoring of serum potassium to maintain
values above 4.0 mEq/L.
Beta-blockers should be strongly discouraged for the treatment of hypertension in
DPP participants. When indicated for the treatment of CAD or tachyarrhythmias, beta-blockers
should be used with caution and will be noted in the subsequent data analysis as
a confounding variable. This applies to labetalol (combined alpha-beta blocker)
as well as both selective and nonselective beta-blockers.
5.2 Lipids
5.2.1 Dietary Treatment
Although the available data suggest that IGT is associated with an increased risk
of atherosclerosis, IGT is not currently designated by the National Cholesterol
Education Program (NCEP) report (National Cholesterol Education Program, 1993) as
one of the cardiovascular risk factors; therefore, for the purposes of diagnosis
and treatment of dyslipidemia in DPP, IGT will not be considered a cardiovascular
risk factor.
The recommended initial dietary treatment for dyslipidemia (NCEP Step I) coincides
exactly with the American Diabetes Association dietary recommendations for management
of diabetes regarding the intake of saturated fat and cholesterol and the approach
to excess body weight management (American Diabetes Association Consensus Statement,
1993). Thus the standard lifestyle recommendations for all DPP participants, independent
of their lipid status, provides adequate initial dietary treatment for those with
hyperlipidemia. Dietary treatment in DPP will be introduced at the time the DPP
treatment is initiated and will be maintained by clinical centers. Primary care
providers will be informed of these efforts. All participants will receive the same
instruction by means of customized handouts that will contain dietary information
based on the American Diabetes Association/NCEP Step I dietary recommendations.
This will meet acceptable standards of care for both IGT and dyslipidemia while
achieving a standardized level of dietary instruction.
Therefore in dyslipidemic participants:
- At 3 months, dietary recommendations will again be provided for dyslipidemic participants
who were identified at baseline. A lipid profile will not be repeated at 3 months
to assess dietary treatment, except in those participants with CVD.
- A lipid profile will be repeated at 6 months to identify participants who may qualify
for lipid lowering drug therapy.
5.2.2 Drug Treatment
The cutpoints for initiating drug therapy for hypercholesterolemia have been recommended
by the NCEP to be at an LDL-cholesterol of >220 mg/dL for premenopausal women
(or men <35 years of age), at >190 mg/dL for low-risk diet-resistant participants,
at >160 mg/dL for high risk participants, and at >130 mg/dL (or less depending
on the primary care provider's judgment) for participants with CVD. Participants
with borderline-high (200-400 mg/dL) or high (400-1000 mg/dL) triglyceride levels
are not routinely recommended for drug therapy unless there is concomitant CVD,
a family history of premature CVD, concomitant hypercholesterolemia and low HDL-cholesterol,
familial dysbetalipoproteinemia or familial combined hyperlipidemia, or a history
of pancreatitis. Pharmacotherapy should be prescribed for participants with triglyceride
levels in the region of 1000 mg/dL or greater. Lastly the NCEP recommends reducing
LDL-cholesterol to <130 mg/dL in individuals with low HDL-cholesterol (35 mg/dL)
and one other CVD risk factor. DPP participants will follow NCEP recommendations
for drug treatment of dyslipidemia.
Dyslipidemia will be diagnosed according to the proposals discussed above and are
summarized in the table below. IGT will not be considered to be a cardiovascular
risk factor. As a secondary outcome, specific lipid levels measured during DPP will
be masked (see section 5.6.3).
However, hyperlipidemia participants will be unmasked to lipid results at 6 months
if they qualify for drug therapy (at 3 months for CVD participants). Cardiovascular
risk factor status will be updated whenever a lipid profile is repeated. Conversion
to diabetes will add one risk factor.
Table 2.
|
|
Diagnosis
|
Diet Therapy Cutpoint and Target for Therapy
|
Drug Therapy Cutpoint
|
|
LDL-cholesterol with < 2 risk factors
|
160 mg/dL (4.15 mmol/L)
|
160 mg/dL (4.15 mmol/L)
|
190 mg/dL (4.90 mmol/L)
|
LDL-cholesterol with
2 risk factors
|
130 mg/dL (3.35 mmol/L)
|
130 mg/dL (3.35 mmol/L)
|
160 mg/dL (4.15 mmol/L)
|
|
LDL-cholesterol with CVD
|
100 mg/dL (2.60 mmol/L)
|
100 mg/dL (2.60 mmol/L)
|
130 mg/dL (3.35 mmol/L)
|
|
Triglyceride
|
400 mg/dL (4.52 mmol/L)
|
200 mg/dL (2.26 mmol/L)
|
400 mg/dL (4.52 mmol/L)*
|
* based on the primary care provider's judgment and according to
NCEP guidelines
5.2.3 Treatment Protocols
- Diet Treatment
All participants independent of lipid status will be instructed in the equivalent
of an NCEP Step I diet on entering DPP. The diet recommendations will be provided
by the centers, and primary care providers will be informed of this. Participants
in the standard lifestyle recommendation groups will receive instruction by means
of customized handouts, and those in the intensive lifestyle intervention group
will receive specific instructions according to the dietary design that has been
developed for this group. Participants will receive repeat dietary instruction using
the same methods described above.
- Pharmacotherapy
Participants whose lipid levels qualify them for drug therapy at 6 months will have
reached a secondary outcome and will be unmasked to lipid levels so that a decision
can be made regarding hypolipidemic drug selection. Primary care providers will
be informed. Thereafter, actual lipid levels will be reported on these participants.
Participants with CVD will have a 3-month lipid profile performed; if their levels
qualify them for pharmacotherapy, they will be unmasked to lipid levels for drug
selection and early initiation of drug treatment.
- Drug Treatment Options
- Pure hypercholesterolemia:
- HMG-CoA Reductase Inhibitor
- Sequestrants
- Pure hypertriglyceridemia:
-
Gemfibrozil (no alternative. Addition of sequestrant may be necessary if LDL cholesterol
rises)
- Combined hyperlipidemia:
- Gemfibrozil plus a sequestrant
- HMG-CoA Reductase Inhibitor
- HMG-CoA Reductase Inhibitor plus gemfibrozil (in selected cases)
5.3 Psychological Diseases and Use of Psychoactive Agents
Severe psychiatric disorders can interfere with the compliance of participants with
research protocols, and some psychoactive drugs are known to alter glucose tolerance
and/or induce weight changes. Due to the high prevalence of psychiatric disorders
in the general population, it is very likely that some participants will develop
them after enrollment in the DPP.
Several psychoactive agents have been reported to interfere with appetite and/or
glucose tolerance (Gray, et al., 1992; Levine, et al., 1989). The different selective
serotonin reuptake inhibitors are considered to be a single class. The use of fluoxetine
up to 20 mg/day (or equivalent doses of other SSRI) is permissible. The use of fluoxetine
(or equivalent doses of other SSRI) at doses higher that 20 mg/day is an exclusionary
criteria for the DPP and use subsequent to randomization will be noted in the data
analysis as a confounding variable.
5.4 Pregnancy
Women with a history of gestational diabetes (GDM) are one of the potential groups
of interest for the DPP. These women, together with many other participants in DPP,
may be of childbearing potential during the course of the DPP. Data from available
cohorts suggest that about 6 percent of women of childbearing age may be expected
to get pregnant in a given year.
5.4.1 Indications During Pregnancy
Metformin is contraindicated in pregnancy although data on adverse effects on the
fetus or the mother are scant. The embryotoxic effects of biguanides have recently
been evaluated in the in vitro cultured mouse embryo model (Denno, et al.,
1994). Because of the lack of teratogenicity of metformin in the few available studies,
this drug is classified by the FDA as pregnancy category B (no evidence of risk
in humans; animal findings negative).
There is no general contraindication for women continuing the exercise intervention
during pregnancy (American Academy of Pediatrics, American College of Obstetricians
and Gynecologists, 1988). The 150 minutes/week target for women in the intensive
lifestyle intervention should not require monitoring, but because of the lack of
data on ketosis with vigorous exercising, regimens that exceed 1000 kcal/week may
require monitoring of ketosis. Dieting for weight loss during pregnancy can be dangerous;
therefore, guidelines for calorie intake (American Academy of Pediatrics, American
College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists, 1988) will be recommended.
Women of childbearing age who are fertile, meet other eligibility requirements,
and wish to participate in the DPP will be informed of the potential risks to a
pregnancy conceived while on any DPP pharmacological treatment. Women who consent
to participate will be asked to practice reliable birth control including systemic
hormones, intrauterine devices, and barrier methods (diaphragm, male or female condom,
cervical cap) with concomitant intravaginal spermicide.
5.4.2 Safety Monitoring
Women in the intensive lifestyle intervention group will be asked to obtain pregnancy
tests if pregnancy is suspected. Women in the pharmacological treatment group will
be asked to complete monthly menstrual diaries and to get immediate pregnancy testing
if their menstrual cycles are more than one week overdue or they otherwise suspect
they are pregnant.
5.4.3 DPP Interventions During Pregnancy
Women randomized to the pharmacological treatment who are found to be pregnant while
taking coded medication will have their coded medication discontinued and be immediately
unmasked to the pharmacological treatment assignment. Information on the potential
teratogenicity of metformin will be provided to both the DPP participant as well
as her provider(s) of obstetrical care in order to facilitate an informed decision
on further handling of the pregnancy.
Recommendations that exercise should continue with a target of 150 minutes/week
per week will be forwarded to the providers of obstetrical care for DPP participants
in the intensive lifestyle intervention who get pregnant during the course of the
DPP. These principles will also apply to those women randomized to standard lifestyle
recommendations.
Pregnancy will require modifying the diet intervention to accommodate the increase
in calories recommended for a healthy pregnancy, and for lactation (American Academy
of Pediatrics, American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists, 1988). The recommended
average daily caloric intake for pregnant women is 30-35 kcal/kg IBW. These recommendations
should be forwarded to the provider(s) of obstetrical care for DPP participants
who get pregnant during the course of the DPP, regardless of the DPP treatment group.
DPP monitoring and visit schedules will be determined by the date of randomization.
5.4.4 DPP Interventions During Breast Feeding
The intensive lifestyle intervention, with caloric requirements adjusted to account
for breast feeding, can be introduced as soon after delivery as is feasible; we
recommend within the first month. Women who choose not to breast feed should return
to their pre-pregnancy lifestyle intervention, including dietary targets, within
the first month following delivery. For women who choose not to breast feed, weight
targets should return to pre-pregnancy levels regardless of extra weight that may
have been gained during pregnancy. For women who breast feed, weight targets should
be suspended until lactation is finished and then should be re-established at pre-pregnancy
levels. Coded medication will be suspended for the duration of breast feeding.
5.4.5 Outcome Assessment Following Pregnancy
DPP participants who become pregnant during the DPP are likely to develop gestational
diabetes, and many of these women will require insulin. The standard of care for
follow-up after gestational diabetes is to assess glucose tolerance at 6-8 weeks
post-partum. Women who become pregnant during the DPP will have outcome assessment
suspended until 6-8 weeks following delivery. This outcome measure following pregnancy
will always be an OGTT. They will then attend the next regularly scheduled outcome
assessment visit based on their original DPP follow-up schedule. Women meeting ADA
criteria for diabetes will have reached the DPP primary outcome.
For those DPP participants who require insulin during pregnancy, assessing the ongoing
need for insulin should begin in the hospital immediately post-partum. Women discharged
on insulin should be evaluated with home glucose monitoring, followed by their providers
of obstetrical care, to determine the ongoing need for insulin. Based upon post-partum
monitoring, some women may remain on insulin or be started on oral hypoglycemic
agents by their obstetrical/primary care provider(s). Participants treated with
insulin or oral agents will not be re-started on their coded medication unless and
until their need for therapy resolves.
There may be some women who are still being treated by their primary care provider(s)
with insulin or oral agents at the time of their first outcome assessment following
pregnancy (i.e., 6-8 weeks following delivery). To ensure standardized assessment
of outcomes, therapy must be stopped for the OGTT. If cessation of therapy is not
possible, two elevated fasting blood glucose determinations may be used to define
an outcome of diabetes in place of the OGTT.
5.5 Smoking
The prevalence of smoking among people with impaired glucose tolerance is estimated
to have declined in the past decade to about 20-25%, compared to the NHANES II data
of 30-35%, and is consistent with U.S. smoking reduction overall (Harris, 1989).
Thus, 800-1000 DPP participants are expected to be current smokers. DPP must follow
the established public health policy to reduce the prevalence of smoking by discussing
smoking as a compounding risk factor for CVD and emphasizing the overall benefits
to health for those who quit.
Recommendations from the National Cancer Institute for practicing physicians include
asking about smoking, advising smokers to quit, and assisting those who want to
stop smoking by providing follow-up (Glynn, et al., 1989). These strategies will
be employed by DPP personnel at the annual visits for participants, with distribution
of educational materials to those expressing an interest in smoking cessation. Simultaneous
referral back to their primary care providers and planned programs can also be offered.
5.6 NIDDM
5.6.1 Diabetes Discovered at Screening
Given the high risk characteristics of the volunteers undergoing screening for participation
in DPP, it is anticipated that approximately 4000 individuals will be found to have
previously unrecognized diabetes. Those individuals who have diabetes mellitus by
ADA criteria will receive an informational letter indicating that they may have
diabetes mellitus and should be seen by their primary care provider or available
community resources for evaluation to confirm the diagnosis of diabetes and to initiate
appropriate therapy. Participants will be given copies of their laboratory studies
for their primary care providers, but DPP personnel will not participate in any
further evaluation or treatment of these participants. Volunteers who do not have
a primary care provider will be referred to local health care facilities.
5.6.2 Interim Visits for Symptoms
Following enrollment and randomization in the DPP, participants will be seen on
a quarterly basis for assessment of adverse events. If a participant develops symptoms
consistent with uncontrolled hyperglycemia, he or she will be instructed to come
to the clinical center for assessment of an adverse event and undergo a fasting
blood glucose determination. This test may be performed locally if needed for safety
reasons; however, a sample must be sent to the CBL for outcome assessment. If the
centrally read fasting glucose is
126 mg/dL, a repeat test will be performed within 6 weeks to confirm the diagnosis.
The participant will have reached the DPP primary outcome if fasting glucose
126 mg/dL persists.
5.6.3 Intervention and Follow-up for Participants with Diabetes and Fasting Glucose
<140 mg/dL
Assuming a 7.5% annual conversion rate in the control group and a 33% reduction
in hazard rate in the intervention groups, 571 participants are anticipated to meet
the DPP primary outcome during the course of the DPP. Participants, investigators,
and primary care providers will be unmasked to the diagnosis of diabetes. In addition,
all subsequent glucose and hemoglobin A1c determinations will be unmasked
to participants and investigators. The pharmacological treatment group assignment
will remain masked.
After informing the participant and the primary care provider of the diagnosis and
explaining the significance, the investigator in conjunction with the primary care
provider will endeavor to maintain the participant on his or her assigned treatment.
Further DPP intervention will include intensification of any lifestyle intervention
to which the participant has been randomized. For participants assigned to the intensive
lifestyle intervention, intensification of diet and exercise with the aim of greater
adherence and improved response will be implemented. For participants randomized
to pharmacological treatment, the standard lifestyle recommendations (which are
consistent with ADA Guidelines) will be reinforced as soon after the diagnosis as
possible and the participant will be seen 1 month and 3 months later (ADA Clinic
Practice Recommendations, 1998). Subsequent reinforcement of standard lifestyle
recommendations will occur at the scheduled 3-month interval visits. In addition,
all participants developing diabetes will be offered self monitoring of blood glucose
(SMBG) with the option of monitoring fasting glucose levels two to three times weekly
as well as during any acute illness or in the event of symptoms such as polydipsia,
polyuria, or polyphagia. SMBG results may be reviewed at quarterly visits and the
participants will be instructed to inform the clinical sites if fasting glucose
determinations exceed 140 mg/dL.
DPP participants will continue to be seen at quarterly intervals for clinical assessment.
Secondary outcome measurements will continue to be performed. In addition, fasting
glucose and hemoglobin A1c determinations will be obtained at quarterly
visits.
5.6.4 Intervention and Follow-up for Participants with Diabetes and Fasting Glucose
140 mg/dL
In the event that participants progress to fasting glucose in excess of 140 mg/dL
on two occasions, coded medication will be discontinued. Participants, investigators,
and primary care providers will remain masked to the pharmacological treatment assignment
until the end of the DPP. A stepped care protocol for treatment of diabetes mellitus
as recommended by the American Diabetes Association will be recommended to the primary
care provider. The protocol will include increased SMBG frequency and therapy with
pharmacologic agents with the goal of achieving pre-prandial capillary glucose measurement
80-120 mg/dL (bedtime values of 100-140 mg/dL) and hemoglobin A1c determinations
< 7%. Additionally, participants will be followed by their primary care providers
for the development of any diabetes-related complications such as retinopathy or
neuropathy. All DPP-related glucose tolerance testing for insulin secretion or insulin
sensitivity studies will be terminated at this time and replaced with unmasked fasting
plasma glucose and hemoglobin A1c values. However, participants will
continue to be followed at scheduled intervals to collect other outcome data including
measurements of cardiovascular outcomes.
5.7 Cardiovascular Disease
Cardiovascular events have been chosen to be one of the outcomes in DPP. The incidence
of CVD is increased in participants with newly diagnosed NIDDM, and the risk of
deaths in non-diabetic participants with impaired glucose tolerance is two times
higher than in participants with normal glucose metabolism. The upper range of postload
glucose distribution in a non-diabetic population is associated with a two- to three-fold
increased mortality in middle-aged men and women (Stamler, et al., 1979; Fuller,
et al., 1980; Eschwege, et al., 1985). On the other hand, many of the cardiovascular
diseases themselves, or their treatments, have an effect on proposed treatments
or outcomes of the DPP, or vice versa.
Cardiovascular diseases (CVD) in participants recruited to the DPP are significant
for three reasons:
- CVD may have an effect on prognosis of the participants recruited,
- The symptoms of CVD may have an effect on the capability of participants to follow
the guidelines of treatment, especially in the intensive lifestyle intervention
group, and
- The conversion rate from IGT to NIDDM may be higher in participants with CVD than
in participants without CVD.
Recommendations
- Exercise Testing
- Participants randomized to the intensive lifestyle intervention group must have
had a symptom-limited maximal exercise tolerance test within 6 months prior to initiation
of any exercise program, or will have a symptom-limited maximal exercise tolerance
test prior to initiation of any exercise program, if they have
- previous hospital verified myocardial infarction; or
- self reported history of "heart attack"; or
- abnormal Q-waves in their ECG > 0.03 seconds in duration.
- Sub-maximal exercise tolerance testing with simultaneous ECG and blood pressure
monitoring will be performed for men older than 40 years and post-menopausal women
not on hormone replacement therapy who have at least two of the following risk factors:
- hypercholesterolemia, S-Chol > 240 mg/dL
- hypertension, systolic BP > 160 and/or diastolic BP > 90 on two separate measurements
or on medication for hypertension
- current smoking
- family history of CVD at the age less than 55 years
No exclusions will be made based on exercise test results, but participants who
are classified by the results to have high risk of cardiovascular complications
during the exercise should not be allowed to participate in the exercise program
until receiving definitive therapy. High risk groups based on the results of exercise
tests are those who have
- angina pectoris at the low exercise level (< 6 METs); or
- ischemic ST segment depression > 2 mm at any level of exercise; or
- decline in systolic blood pressure > 15 mm Hg; or
- ventricular arrhythmia induced by exercise.
All other participants who have symptoms or signs of CVD during the exercise test
are eligible to participate in the exercise program, but the level of the program
must be individually adjusted. These participants must be taught to measure their
heart rate during exercise and to keep exercise at a safe level (i.e., no symptoms
of angina pectoris or dyspnea on exertion and maintenance of heart rate at least
10 BPM lower than that level at which symptoms appeared during the exercise tolerance
test) (Fletcher, et al., 1990).
- Myocardial infarction or unstable angina during the DPP
Participants who have myocardial infarction or unstable angina during the DPP should
be treated according to the community standards. All participants in the pharmacological
treatment groups will be eligible to continue to follow the DPP protocol after myocardial
infarction without any major interruptions, unless specific contraindications arise.
According to the American Heart Association Guidelines, a submaximal exercise test
should be performed within 3 weeks after an acute MI (Fletcher, et al., 1990). A
maximal exercise test should be done more than 3 weeks after myocardial infarction,
when the participant is ready to resume full activities. The participants in the
intensive lifestyle intervention group should discontinue the exercise program after
myocardial infarction until the risk stratification by exercise testing is done
6-8 weeks post-MI. The decision whether these participants are allowed to continue
the exercise program or whether their exercise program should be modified is based
on the exercise tolerance test.
- New angina pectoris
Participants who have new symptoms suggesting angina pectoris during the DPP should
be treated by their primary care providers according to the community standards
and cardiological evaluation, and exercise tolerance testing may be recommended
to them. Participants in the intensive lifestyle intervention group will have their
exercise program discontinued until the cardiological evaluation has been performed,
and their eligibility to continue the exercise protocol should be reconsidered after
the results of the evaluation are available. Participants assigned to pharmacological
treatment can continue the DPP protocol without any major interruptions.
- PTCA or coronary by-pass (CABG)
According to the American Heart Association Guidelines, exercise tolerance testing
should be performed in the routine follow-up of participants who have undergone
PTCA and to every participant who complains of chest pain during exercise after
these procedures. The participants of DPP who undergo PTCA or CABG during the DPP
should be allowed to discontinue the exercise component of the DPP protocol for
up to 6 months, if necessary. After this period their health status should be re-evaluated
to determine their continuation in the exercise protocol, with results of exercise
tolerance testing playing a pivotal role. If these participants are in the intensive
lifestyle intervention group, they will follow a modified exercise protocol, for
the rest of the DPP, if necessary.
- Medical treatment of CVD
Beneficial effects of beta-blockers and ACE inhibitors on mortality and recurrent
CVD events after myocardial infarctions are so clear that we cannot restrict their
use after myocardial infarctions. The participants with heart failure should be
treated according to the community standards and no restrictions on the use of any
drugs will be made.
[Top]
6. Retention Monitoring and Recovery of Inactive Participants
Key to both the power and generalizability of findings of DPP is the retention of
a large portion of participants throughout the entire DPP; however, recruitment,
randomization, and retention of participants for DPP is likely to be difficult.
Some of this is due to the fact that participants, although they will have IGT,
are asymptomatic. Furthermore, IGT is not presently designated as a disease. In
addition, participants who are interested in preventing diabetes will have no choice
about the treatment group to which they are assigned. It is anticipated that persons
who contemplate participation because of an interest in lifestyle modification may
be quite different from those who are willing to take medications. Additional difficulty
is imposed by the fact that some test results are masked. However, the greatest
problem will probably be due to the demands placed upon participants in DPP with
respect to time commitment, transportation, parking, and child or elder care, which
vary considerably among the target populations. Steps to maximize retention of participants
to the DPP are based upon these considerations.
Since a decision to discontinue follow-up visits is a clear loss to DPP, such decisions
are considered not irrevocable and recovery efforts are required. Thus, enrolled
participants who make a decision to discontinue follow-up are told they are welcome
to return to DPP should they change their minds. Reasons for deciding to discontinue
follow-up are explored with the participant. Participants continue to be contacted
on a progressively less frequent schedule, starting monthly and decreasing to semi-annually
to remind them of the opportunity to re-enter DPP and to maintain contact with them
for possible recruitment for the final assessment at the end of DPP.
6.1 Steps to Maximize Adherence and Retention
Adherence and retention in DPP is fostered by a comprehensive array of participant
education procedures which requires the interest, responsiveness, and continuous
availability of professional staff; motivational programs, group activities, and
rewards deployed according to the judgment of each participating center; plus removal
of barriers to participation. Central training for the Program and Recruitment Coordinators
in the techniques of "motivational interviewing" assists them in providing
a framework based on this concept at each center. In addition to providing education
regarding details of the interventions, much of staff contact with participants
is of a general, supportive nature, addressing frustrations with DPP, problems in
maintaining adherence, and even general life issues participants may face.
6.1.1 Social Support
The underlying philosophy of retention of participants is to encourage Program and
Recruitment Coordinators, case managers, receptionists, and all other staff to interact
with participants in a manner which enhances their sense of bonding to DPP. Additional
tactics such as newsletters, outings, birthday and anniversary cards, and the like
may be construed as facilitators of a sense of social connection with DPP, its staff,
and fellow participants. It is likely that these connections and not the more tangible
rewards themselves are the more important incentives to retention.
Because the kinds of activities and rewards that promote the social connections
that bond participants to DPP will take very different shapes in different communities
and groups, a high level of local development and design of these is desirable.
This is facilitated by a menu of nationally available materials and strategies and
frequent contact among centers to exchange suggestions, such as
- Quarterly newsletters, developed nationally but able to be tailored locally, including
items of interest about participants and staff in different DPP sites to encourage
a sense of community within DPP;
- Individual incentives that are less expensive when purchased in bulk and are ordered
by Centers as desired from the Coordinating Center, such as mugs, T-shirts, and
caps designed to raise a sense of identity with, and pride, in DPP;
- Locally purchased items such as movie tickets, bowling passes, sports tickets, anniversary
cards, exercise video and audio tapes, and gift certificates to create a sense of
identity with the local center;
- Refreshments (coffee, tea, sodas) for participants at clinic visits;
- Group social gatherings such as holiday parties, picnics, or sporting or cultural
events;
- Additional inexpensive tokens such as key chains, pens, pencils, etc., that may
be purchased in bulk if desired by several Centers.
6.1.2 Removal of Barriers to Participation
In addition to these incentives, resources for removing barriers to participation
such as child or elder care, transportation, and parking expenses are important
considerations. These resources are considered separate from the incentives, as
necessary support, to enable participants to adhere to treatment regimens (compliance)
and to attend outcomes data collection visits (retention). These resources, given
as cash, transportation vouchers, or parking passes, may vary greatly among the
Centers.
6.1.3 Honoraria
In addition, an honorarium will be paid to participants in recognition of the time
and effort spent in the DPP. All participants receive this payment twice a year
if participants have successfully completed scheduled visits and procedures.
6.2 Monitoring Retention
Recovery of patients on inactive follow-up uses protocols that are standardized
according to each of the DPP treatment groups' attendance and adherence demands.
These protocols include criteria for identifying participants whose level of adherence
and/or attendance should trigger recovery efforts, as well as a graded hierarchy
of recovery efforts. This hierarchy of efforts ranges from brief telephone discussion
of missed meetings to an individualized counseling session with the case manager
or other appropriate staff member in which the participant can review reasons for
staying in DPP, concerns regarding DPP, and decisions about remaining a participant.
6.2.1 Visit Monitoring
There is a computer-based monitoring system to record each visit with participants.
One purpose of this system is to identify participants who are having problems with
adherence to the protocol. Another purpose of the system is to identify participants
who may be candidates for discontinuing follow-up of DPP and thus qualify for recovery
efforts.
6.2.2 Measures of Stress and Social Support
The following self-administered questionnaires will be completed during the DPP
(see section 12 for frequency of administration)
for purposes of predicting adherence and retention, and determining the positive
or negative impact of DPP treatments.
- Retention and Treatment Monitoring Measures (Form Q06):
- Life events index
- Social provisions scale
- Family household assessment
- DPP-Specific Support Measures (Forms Q09 and Q10):
- Baseline Visit (Form Q09)
- Follow-up Visits (Form Q10)
[Top]
|